“I do it this way, and it’s always worked for me”
“I’m not saying this is the only way to do it, it’s just what I do”
“I’ve done it this way for years”
These are just a few classic arguments that are used to justify choices in animal keeping. Often with, no guesses, lighting and heating; processes that are based in science, and not experience.
It’s one thing to say you’ve been washing your car a certain way for years, or ironing your shirt a certain way for years. But when ‘it’ is providing high quality measurable animal welfare, doing ‘it’ the same way for many years is indicative of someone not willing to change with the times and advancements in understanding.
I’m in split minds about why this would be. Is it that people do not want to think that they’ve been doing ‘it’ in a way that could have been ‘wrong’ for so long? Or perhaps there’s some deeper thing going on – are these people the sort of people who didn’t like school, gaining academic skills, or is there maybe some other psychological reason? I suppose that doesn’t really matter as ultimately there is one shared, unifying, feature of them: they use the same excuses.
It’s difficult not to draw quick conclusions, because the people who make these arguments are nearly always old old-fashioned keepers, old-fashioned pet store workers, or people who have been away from animal keeping for some time and making a return.
I see it a lot with placement of lamps, the use of older lighting technology, and the placement of thermostat probes. These are based in logic, science, and reason. As I alluded to earlier, they’re not the same as washing a car.
I think it’s particularly worrying when pet store workers act like this. In the UK, such workers are legislated to conduct Continuing Professional Development. This means that they should – and are legally required to – remain up-to-date with scientific understanding, and be accepting of changes within the industry. This isn’t the Wild West, or the same pet shop they opened in the 80’s.
Lighting and heating animals is a science, and our methods for best replicating nature change as our understanding of the world changes. An analogy can be drawn with treating disease: there are many different methods of preventing and treating a plethora of ailments that simply wouldn’t have happened 10 years ago – to the point where a person wouldn’t be caught dead doing some of the barbaric things of yesteryear. The use of PTFE, cheap cladding on buildings, asbestos, and lobotomy procedures are all extreme examples of “it works” or “not the only way to do it”.
That’s not to say that there’s definitely a ‘right way’ to light and heat our animals. It would be more appropriate to say it’s more ‘the most appropriate given our current understanding’. I therefore hold the position that many cases involving lighting and heating our animals, there are not two ways to skin a cat.
